Introduction
Victims
Suspects
Witnesses
Ripper Letters
Police Officials
Official Documents
Press Reports
Victorian London
Message Boards
Ripper Media
Authors
Dissertations
Timelines
Games & Diversions
Photo Archive
Ripper Wiki
Casebook Examiner
Ripper Podcast
About the Casebook

 Search:


Most Recent Posts:
Other Mysteries: ** The Murder of Julia Wallace ** - by etenguy 12 minutes ago.
Catherine Eddowes: Jack's Escape from Mitre Square - by Juniper4576 32 minutes ago.
Witnesses: If Schwartz Lied ... - by JeffHamm 55 minutes ago.
Catherine Eddowes: Jack's Escape from Mitre Square - by Juniper4576 1 hour ago.
General Police Discussion: Did PC Long see the Ripper in Goulston Street? - by Simon Wood 1 hour ago.
Pub Talk: Favourite Quotations - by c.d. 1 hour ago.
General Victim Discussion: Ripperology and victim research - by jmenges 1 hour ago.
General Victim Discussion: Ripperology and victim research - by jmenges 1 hour ago.

Most Popular Threads:
General Discussion: A new front in the history wars? A new article on 'the five' - (20 posts)
Other Mysteries: ** The Murder of Julia Wallace ** - (20 posts)
Witnesses: If Schwartz Lied ... - (17 posts)
Pub Talk: Favourite Quotations - (13 posts)
General Police Discussion: Did PC Long see the Ripper in Goulston Street? - (6 posts)
Catherine Eddowes: Jack's Escape from Mitre Square - (6 posts)


By Ear and Eyes: The Whitechapel Murders, Jack the Ripper and the Murder of Mary Jane Kelly
Karyo Mageallan
Longshot Publishing, 2005
ISBN: 0-9550240-0-5
Softcover

Casebook Review:

A strong re-examination of the crimes. Magellan provides an in-depth analysis of each Ripper murder, based almost exclusively on the medical and inquest evidence. In his analysis, Magellan removes Mary Kelly from the list of Ripper victims (he believes she was killed by an opportunistic copycat), and adds Mackenzie (1889) and Coles (1891), suggesting there were strong similarities in the modus operandi which connect the latter two victims with Nichols, Chapman, Stride and Eddowes.

From there, Magellan continues onward to examine (and dismiss) a handful of suspects - Druitt, Kosminski, Ostrog, Tumblety, Klosowski and Sickert. He also offers a critical re-examination of the Macnaghten memoranda, suggesting that the document was heavily flawed and largely responsible for misleading modern-day scholars into believing the "myth" of the canonical five victims.

By Ears and Eyes reads at times more like a doctoral dissertation than a traditional Ripper book. It is certainly not intended for the novice Ripperologist. Although some of his conclusions may be difficult for modern-day students of the case to accept, it is nevertheless refreshing to read such a thorough re-examination of the case. Recommended.


Related pages:
  Karyo Magellan
       Dissertations: The Victorian Medico-Legal Autopsy 
       Dissertations: The Victorian Medico-Legal Autopsy: Part II